Dental Discount Plans vs Insurance: Which Is Better?
Compare dental discount plans to dental insurance. Learn the pros and cons of each, cost differences, and which option saves you more money on dental care.
Dental Discount Plans vs Dental Insurance
Dental discount plans and dental insurance both help reduce dental costs, but they work very differently. Insurance pays a portion of your dental bills after you pay premiums, deductibles, and copays. Discount plans give you reduced rates at participating dentists in exchange for an annual membership fee. Understanding the differences helps you choose the better option for your situation.
How Dental Discount Plans Work
Dental discount plans (also called dental savings plans) are membership programs, not insurance. You pay an annual fee ($80-$200/year) and get access to discounted rates at participating dentists—typically 10-60% off standard fees.
- Annual membership fee: $80-$200 for individuals, $150-$300 for families
- Discounts: 10-60% off depending on procedure
- No waiting periods—use immediately after joining
- No annual maximums—unlimited discounts
- No deductibles or copays—just pay the discounted fee
- No claims to file—dentist handles everything
- No pre-existing condition exclusions
- Must use participating dentists for discounts
How Dental Insurance Works
Dental insurance is coverage that pays a percentage of your dental costs after you meet your deductible. You pay monthly premiums and share costs through deductibles, copays, and coinsurance.
- Monthly premiums: $20-$50 for individuals, $50-$150 for families
- Annual deductible: $50-$150 typically
- Coverage: 100% preventive, 80% basic, 50% major (typical)
- Annual maximum: $1,000-$2,500 cap on what insurance pays
- Waiting periods: 6-24 months for basic and major services
- Network requirements: Best benefits with in-network dentists
- Claims paperwork: May need to submit claims or wait for processing
- Pre-existing conditions may not be covered immediately
Cost Comparison Example
Let's compare costs for a crown ($1,200 retail price):
- Dental Insurance: $50/month premium ($600/year) + $100 deductible + 50% copay ($400) = $1,100+ total cost
- Dental Discount Plan: $150/year membership + $720 (40% off crown) = $870 total cost
- For this procedure, the discount plan saves $230+
- However, insurance may be better if you need multiple major procedures
- Insurance is often better for preventive care (100% covered vs ~20% discount)
- Discount plans shine for expensive procedures above insurance maximums
When to Choose a Dental Discount Plan
Discount plans may be the better choice in these situations:
- You need major dental work immediately (no waiting periods)
- You've already hit your insurance annual maximum
- You need expensive procedures like implants (often not covered by insurance)
- You're generally healthy with few dental needs
- You don't have access to employer dental insurance
- You want predictable costs without claims hassles
- You want to combine with insurance for costs above the maximum
When to Choose Dental Insurance
Insurance may be the better choice in these situations:
- Your employer offers dental insurance at low or no cost
- You have ongoing dental needs and want predictable coverage
- You prioritize preventive care (covered at 100%)
- You can wait through the waiting period before needing major work
- You want the security of knowing large bills are partially covered
- You prefer the structure of defined benefits
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a dental discount plan?
A dental discount plan is a membership program where you pay an annual fee to access discounted rates at participating dentists. It's not insurance—you pay the discounted fee directly. There are no waiting periods, deductibles, or annual maximums.
Are dental discount plans worth it?
It depends on your needs. Discount plans are often worth it for expensive procedures, immediate care needs, and costs above insurance maximums. They're less valuable for routine preventive care, which insurance typically covers at 100%.
Can I have both dental insurance and a discount plan?
Yes. Many people use insurance for preventive care and routine procedures, then use a discount plan for costs above their annual maximum or for procedures insurance doesn't cover (like implants).
How much do dental discount plans save?
Discount plans typically save 10-60% off standard fees depending on the procedure. Simple services like cleanings may have smaller discounts (10-20%), while major services like crowns and dentures often have larger discounts (40-60%).
Do dental discount plans have waiting periods?
No. Unlike dental insurance, discount plans have no waiting periods. You can use your membership immediately after joining, which makes them ideal for urgent dental needs.
What's the difference between a dental discount plan and dental insurance?
Insurance pays a percentage of your dental bills (after premiums and deductibles) up to an annual maximum. Discount plans give you reduced rates in exchange for an annual membership fee—you pay the discounted price directly with no claims or maximums.
Need Help Choosing?
Upload your treatment plan and we'll help you compare the total cost with insurance versus a discount plan for your specific situation.
Related Guides
Lower Your Dental Bill
Dental Insurance Annual Maximum: What It Is and How to Maximize It
Your dental insurance annual maximum is the most your plan will pay per year. Learn how to maximize this benefit, plan treatments strategically, and avoid paying out-of-pocket.
What Does Dental Insurance Cover? Complete Coverage Guide
Learn what dental insurance covers and what it doesn't. Understand coverage levels for preventive, basic, major, and cosmetic procedures plus common exclusions.